ఉపాయం

ఉపాయం - 417 Desi parental expectations and “Bada Naam” pressure!

The Approach

Topics

ఉపాయం - 417

From “Papa Kehte Hain” (Qayamat Se Qayamat Tak, 1988) to “Chaand Taare” (Yes Boss, 1997), a handful of Bollywood songs quietly carried the emotional vocabulary of an entire generation of Desi parenting. They were not merely melodies looping on cassette players in the 1990s; they were philosophies, anxieties, and hopes embedded in lyrics—things Indian parents, especially those raising children abroad, rarely articulated directly. “Papa kehte hain bada naam karega” spoke in the voice of expectation. It was a promise made on behalf of a child long before the child had fully encountered the world. Study well. Choose a respectable path. Become someone whose success can be named, measured, and proudly explained to relatives and neighbors. Beneath the confidence of that line lived a quieter fear—that drifting, uncertainty, or delay might close doors forever. “Chaand taare tod laun”, on the other hand, whispered something more expansive. It observed possibility without a résumé, ambition without a fixed endpoint. It suggested a world open to imagination and daring, where life could be shaped by curiosity rather than only careful planning. For Indian-American youth, these two messages often arrived together, creating an inner tension: decide early and reassure everyone, or explore freely and risk appearing unfocused. Then came a third voice—louder, brasher, and unmistakably post-liberalization: “I am the best” (Phir Bhi Dil Hai Hindustani, 1999). Unlike the earlier songs, this one did not ask for permission or wait for approval. It asserted worth before achievement, confidence before credentials. In many ways, it foreshadowed the cultural world Indian-American youth would later inherit—one that rewarded self-belief, visibility, and branding alongside discipline and restraint. For many Desi parents, however, this message felt unsettling. Confidence without proof looked like arrogance. Self-assertion without responsibility looked risky. “I am the best” clashed sharply with the ethic of earning praise quietly and letting results speak. Yet there was another song, softer and often overlooked, that offered a different resolution altogether: “Aaj Main Upar” (Khamoshi, 1996). This song did not shout ambition or dramatize expectation. It expressed joy rooted in competence, movement, and alignment—being “up” not because you had defeated others or fulfilled a script, but because effort, skill, and feeling had momentarily come together. It was neither anxious like “Papa kehte hain” nor untethered like “Chaand taare,” nor performative like “I am the best.” It suggested something rarer: quiet confidence born of immersion and lived experience. Those who made up their minds early—often in high school—seemed to carry a quiet relief alongside that confidence. A clear direction reduced confusion. Courses, extracurriculars, and internships lined up neatly. Parents relaxed, conflicts diminished, and in competitive fields that rewarded early preparation, decisiveness offered real advantages. Yet many of these choices were made before a young person had lived enough to truly know themselves. Dreams borrowed from family expectations crowded out talents that surfaced later. Identity became tied too tightly to a title, and when setbacks occurred—as they inevitably did—the sense of failure felt catastrophic. Exhaustion followed quietly when motivation came more from obligation than meaning. Others postponed deciding until college, choosing instead to explore. Exposure to real subjects, real work, and real people allowed decisions to grow out of experience rather than fear or prestige. These paths tended to be more resilient, shaped by self-knowledge and adaptable to a rapidly changing world. Motivation emerged internally rather than being imposed. Still, this route carried its own weight. Watching peers move ahead with apparent certainty created the uneasy feeling of falling behind. Family anxiety intensified, often expressed gently but persistently: So what will you do? Exploration demanded maturity, discipline, and honesty, and some doors did narrow without early prerequisites. What many 90s parents never said out loud was that they were not truly demanding certainty at sixteen. They were afraid—of instability, of regret, of wasted opportunity—fears shaped by lives where choice was limited and failure unforgiving. Their insistence on clarity was less about the specific profession and more about a deep discomfort with drifting without effort, humility, or direction. A healthier path for Indian-American youth lies somewhere between these songs. Direction matters, even if the destination changes. Skills matter more than labels. Exploration is valuable when paired with accountability. Confidence is powerful when earned, and ambition is sustainable when grounded. No one needs to know their final profession in high school, but everyone needs to learn how to commit sincerely, reassess honestly, and grow without performing certainty for approval. In the end, “Papa kehte hain” was always about responsibility. “Chaand taare” was about hope. “I am the best” was about self-belief in a world that demands visibility. And “Aaj main upar” was about the quiet joy of being fully engaged—doing something well, for real, in the moment. The task was never to choose one voice and silence the others, but to learn how to live between them—with ambition that listens, confidence that is earned, and dreams grounded enough to endure!